From Tallahassee take I-10 east to Exit 217.  From Monticello take I-10 west to exit 217.  Go south on Highway 59 through Lloyd.  From the railroad track go one mile further and turn right on Whitehouse Road.  The Painted Pony is a mile and a third down Whitehouse Road on the right. 
Turn on Painted Pony Trail and you are here!

Consult map for other routes.

Please note, internet and GPS directions are unreliable!!!
Click on map to enlarge.